Clare Best


Traces at Austrian Cultural Forum London, 3rd April – 8th June 2012.


‘Reality is not simply there, it does not simply exist: it must be sought out and won,’ – Paul Celan, 1958.


The discovery of two small family photographs in an old suitcase that had belonged to her great uncle, Hugo Hecker, was the event that sparked photographer Julia Winckler’s project to witness, seek out and preserve the story of Hugo’s family, most of whom had perished in the holocaust.

Winckler’s quest became a remarkable story in itself, involving multiple photographic explorations, journeys to Kraków and Auschwitz, and research into historical records. Her scrupulous methods of visual and imaginative enquiry have brought the loss and absence of these lives into a new presence. In this extraordinary exhibition Winckler’s story and the traces of Hugo Hecker’s family are woven into the most compelling visual poetry.

Robert Lowell said, ‘A poem is an event … not the record of an event.’ This show is an event because it enables the viewer to re-realise loss and discovery, absence and presence. Winckler meticulously re-photographed each of the individuals from the original photos, in order to respect and resuscitate their identities. The resulting images are monumental in their realism and in their abstraction. The closer you approach them, the more they disappear, anew, into memory.

Winckler’s work sings with love and art, and a delicacy and care that are rare and moving. She truly brings back to life some essence that had vanished. There is once again presence in the absence – in these haunting faces, their eyes dark and sunken, their expressions so recognisably and universally human. The appearance of these people, and their disappearance – both are present, and somehow miraculously reintegrated. Several days after I saw the show I still awoke each morning with the faces clearly in my mind. No loss at this stage, then, for those who encounter what Winckler has created.

The show has been curated with great attention to detail, consistent with the entire project. I appreciated the fact that the images are not captioned. It made me use my eyes properly, relating one image to another, rather than to a string of words.

How bold to tackle a theme as well-documented as the disappearances of the holocaust. How creative to approach it like this, making the private public, the individual universal, transforming the most humble photographs into images so utterly powerful.



To discover more content exclusive to our print and digital editions, subscribe here to receive a copy of The London Magazine to your door every two months, while also enjoying full access to our extensive digital archive of essays, literary journalism, fiction and poetry.

Dearest reader! Our newsletter!

Sign up to our newsletter for the latest content, freebies, news and competition updates, right to your inbox. From the oldest literary periodical in the UK.

You can unsubscribe any time by clicking the link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or directly on Find our privacy policies and terms of use at the bottom of our website.