An Almost Dancer, Robert Nye, Greenwich Exchange, £9.99 (hardback), £7.99 (paperback)

A poem is truly mystical only when it encompasses physical and spiritual orders of reality in a vision that strikes the reader as a spontaneous account of experience. The creative imagination is fired with a gift of grace. Robert Nye has been writing mystical poems throughout his long career.

Nye achieves such visions in his new collection, An Almost Dancer, through the intensity of his gaze. His starting point in the poems, ‘Bicycling with Birds’, ‘Mentchikoffs’, ‘Drinking Hot Chocolate in the Rain’, ‘In Still Winter’ and in the title poem, is solid, physical reality. ‘Drinking Hot Chocolate in the Rain’ begins in a cardboard cup and then soars in pure exaltation:

There in the market by the coffee-stall

I saw the world turned inside-out. The rain

Flew upwards like so many crystal sparks

Returning to the glory of the sun.

The sensuous physicality of the cardboard cup, the vanilla pod and the falling, and rising, rain creates and resolves the great paradox: through the trance-like power of the creative imagination Nye transmutes the mundane to a spiritual experience and yet leaves the physical world intact.

‘Going On’ creates a similar poetic figure. A man carries a coffee pot and a cake along a crowded pavement near Notre Dame. As he walks his simple errand assumes the finality of a last supper and a pilgrimage ‘Towards a room all of his own.’

Three daring poems – the perfect four-line miniature, ‘The Ghost of Chatterton’, ‘Menocchio’s Crime’ and ‘The Lady with the Dog’ – move from pollution to purity. Chatterton’s ghost is detected by the poet’s sense of smell rather than sight: ‘A scent half smegma and half innocence.’ Nye may know that there was, and perhaps still is, an Aztec goddess of filth, Tlazolteotl, who devours excrement and purifies it. Purification rites appear throughout Nye’s work, from his juvenilia to ‘Menocchio’s Crime’ in this new collection. The crime is that Menocchio affirms God and the genealogy of angels through worms he finds in a piece of mouldy cheese: ‘Glory came forth as light from putrefaction!’ The real crime, Nye’s as well as Menocchio’s, is ‘that of any poet/Who dares think big in homely images’; and in a rare explicit statement of religious doctrine Nye concludes:

The only cure for this is still well-known:

To be made clean by purgatorial flame

So that you may be one with the eternal.

Nye is more concerned with mortality – his own and that of others – in An Almost Dancer than in previous collections. ‘Valentinus’, an elegy in rhyming triplets for the poet, critic and biographer, Martin Seymour-Smith, and ‘A Postcard from Crete’, an elegy for the author and literary agent, Giles Gordon, are written in a colloquial style that reads like conversations with the living dead.

When he considers his own mortality Nye writes without morbidity or alarm: death is wholly admissible, wholly natural. ‘Gone Now’ is a song in which the refrain and the simple physical act of a man and woman cutting grass become an original metaphor of flesh and grass. ‘Request’ is a little echo of Nye’s novel, The Late Mr. Shakespeare (soon to be republished) in which the narrator is the fictitious character, Pickleherring. He asks the way to Pickle Herring Street and says: ‘It’s where I lived/When I was happy years ago’ – the place, that is, of the creative imagination at work and at play. ‘Instructions for a Burial’ (first published in The London Magazine, October/November 2010) seemed, on a first reading, similar to R. L. Stevenson’s ‘Requiem’, but the similarity is in the subject matter only. Nye imagines his death more intimately. When he ends the poem with the near-repetition of the opening line, ‘Bury me in a rut on Clay Pit Hill’, he creates the dual effect of sinking back into the earth and recalling the event as if it had already happened.

There is humour, too, in An Almost Dancer. ‘Runes’, the longest poem in the collection, is a ballad of childhood and a delightful piece of serious play. The schoolboy’s faith in the little daily rules of magic and his compulsive, ritual enactment of the rules are the beginnings of his faith in poetry. ‘First Love’ combines a finely controlled pathos with small-boy silliness and innocence: the infatuated boy stands in the rain outside Muriel Lawson’s house until the girl tells him to go away because he is making her father ill. In ‘Matches’, the poem that opens the collection, Nye recalls his four year-old self staring at matchsticks in a patch of melting tar. He realises that even then ‘I stared at them and saw the way love sees’. Since that time he has been ‘Transfixed as always by simplicities’.

An Almost Dancer confirms Robert Nye’s standing as a complete practitioner of the literary illusions of simplicity and inevitability. Simplicity is the effect a poet achieves through his love of and respect for language; he achieves inevitability through the unity and intensity of his vision and through what can be called poetic intelligence. In ‘Valentinus’ Nye writes:

Not that it’s ever simple to make sense

At least when living in the present tense,

Or to be more than your intelligence.

No poet attains complete mastery of the art and craft – there is always a better poem to be written – but Robert Nye comes as close to completeness as any living English-language poet.


Review by James Aitchison

Dearest reader! Our newsletter!

Sign up to our newsletter for the latest content, freebies, news and competition updates, right to your inbox. From the oldest literary periodical in the UK.

You can unsubscribe any time by clicking the link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or directly on Find our privacy policies and terms of use at the bottom of our website.